Real Time Settlement, A Unique Piece of The BlockChain

One of the things I never understood about back office financial payment systems was settlement.  Why did it take so long for things to settle?   In the futures world where I lived, we had daily settlement with corresponding payment, and collection.  But, everywhere else, it took days.

Blockchain can change that and it has some pretty big ramifications.

One of the things that financial people are focused on now post 2008 financial crisis is risk.  The futures industry requires a lot more margin to hold positions.  In Lean Hogs, prior to 2008, it was $50 to hold a spread.  Post crash, $1800 dollars per spread.  Margin changes, but traders will never see $50 ever again.

The futures clearinghouse works exactly like a closed blockchain.  What does the financial world look like if the same concept is unleashed?

It’s going to change stock trading.  Markets will be much more efficient because stock will get transferred and settled that day.  Variance will be taken out of the settlement chain, allowing banks and traders to use cash for positions more efficiently than they do today.  That should lead to lower costs and more profits.  This is back office efficiency, not front end speed efficiency.

There are lots of anomalies in stock trading today.  Big banks fudge the numbers on stocks and borrow them to short.  In a recent settlement with the US Department of Justice, Goldman Sachs will pay a $2.385 billion civil monetary penalty, make $875 million in cash payments and provide $1.8 billion in consumer relief.  It sounds like a lot of money, and it is.  But, I bet they made considerably more than that.  It also doesn’t account for all the knock on effects in other markets that were affected by their illegal activity.  It wasn’t just the mortgage market that fell apart in 2008, all asset and commodity markets tumbled in value.

A few entities dominate back office clearing in finance today.  Blockchain can totally upend that oligopoly.  The members of that oligopoly are trying to figure out what the cost/opportunity costs of fighting the change are today.   If they think they can make more money using blockchain, the transition will go a lot quicker.  If not, look for a lot of regulatory battles at the SEC, Department of Treasury and other regulators.

Credit card payment processing is highly centralized.  Currently, the bitcoin network isn’t fast enough to process payments like existing networks.  But, it’s early and technology changes.  There are some things that the bitcoin network has to figure out before they can compete.  One thing I wonder about; when processes are centralized, they can do a lot, but they can never do as much as a network.  How long does it take the bitcoin network to figure it out-and does that network of miners have to centralize to do it?

A corollary is in futures trading.  In the pit, we had a closed centralized network.  On the screen, we blew the network wide open and volume increased exponentially.  But, for that volume to increase exponentially, it had to centralize into several HFT firms from a lot of independent traders.  This is not unlike the change that will happen with miners when the bitcoin network goes to larger block sizes.  To be clear, I am not suggesting this is “bad or good”; it is merely an observation and a metaphor.

Blockchain obviously will change title search in real estate.  It will change back office processes in the trading of muni bonds, and other assets.  No longer will the market have to pay someone to do research to find out if something has a “clear” title.

This is why people have pivoted to blockchain.  If you talk about Bitcoin, most people think you are insane.  But, Bitcoin and blockchain are linked.  There isn’t one without the other.  If you post something on the blockchain and it has no bitcoin attached to it, there isn’t any value created.  This doesn’t mean governments will abandon their fiat currency anytime soon.  Far from it.  But, they will have to wrap their heads and operations around bitcoin.

 

Economic Freedom and Economic Opportunity

The US is out of the top ten countries in the world by the measurement of economic freedom.  That’s definitely not cool.  Hong Kong has always been number one.  Totally weird to me since they are a part of communist …






David Rubentstein of Carlyle Group; Mensch

Last night I had the opportunity to listen to David Rubenstein of Carlyle Group.  I enjoy listening to stories told by people that started up a business and were successful at it.  You can learn a lot from them.  We …






What Needs To Be Present For Two Sided Market Models

There are a lot of companies that try to execute two sided market models.  They are really hard to pull off.  But, when they work, they are sticky.  They have the potential to generate some network effects and create a …






New People Mean New Ideas And Freshness

One of the things that scares me a bit these days is how people view immigration.  Politicians are using it to scare people or make them feel guilty.  They are offering up a false dichotomy of choice.  It’s either all …






Nothing Beats Growth, Nothing

McKinsey did a study on startups.  They found that if you don’t grow fast, you die slowly.  I think this is true.  CB Insights also too a look at it.  Their findings lead to the same conclusion as McKinsey. One …






Hope For The Future

Today the Iowa primaries play out…..finally.  I was checking my Twitter feed this morning, and I saw this tweet from Balaji S. Srinivasan. He is a venture capital partner at a16z and heavily immersed in Bitcoin. 1/ Trump/Sanders are what …






The New York Times Is Dumber Than I Thought

Yesterday, The New York Times editorial board called for transaction taxes on trading financial instruments.  Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders favor transaction taxes. They are dumber than I thought. I have written about transaction taxes before here, here, here and …






Time To Restructure

Today my friend David Gaffen tweeted Exclusive: Puerto Rico creditors asked to take 45 pct cut on debt – sources https://t.co/MhDOsZbGeJ via Reuters — David Gaffen (@davidgaffen) January 30, 2016 Puerto Rico is bankrupt. But, so is Illinois. So is …






Do You Have The Drive, Or Don’t You?

One thing every early stage investor says is “we invest in people first”.  You hear it again and again in different formats.  Do you bet on the jockey or the horse?  Professor Steve Kaplan did research and found at seed …






Winner Take All-Monopoly Takes None

One of the reasons we started Hyde Park Angels was to change the culture in the entrepreneurial community in Chicago.  Chicago had what a real estate developer would call “good bones”. We had: Top schools (Northwestern, Chicago, Illinois) Top entrepreneurial …






Corporate Inversions-It’s Just Math

This year, we have seen the stock market open up down 8.2%.  It won’t be coming back anytime soon.  Not only have all the Herculean Keynesian efforts by governments failed, but government policy is creating a climate where it’s very …






Cracks in Big Venture

The Big Venture formula that people read about always made little sense to someone like me.   I was reading Danny Crichton‘s article in TechCrunch and found myself thinking back to 1999.  Here is the formula as relayed by Danny: …






Locked My Keys In The Car

Yesterday, we were babysitting my daughters dog.  I put a photo of him on PeggSite.  We decided to drive out to the Forest Preserve and take him for a walk.  We drove out, fought traffic on the Ike, walked around, …






The National Cattlemen Say Markets Are Broken

Here is a letter from the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association to the CME.   The reason I post it is not to indict CME.  I post it because it is indicative of a lot of markets.  The cattle market is …






A Valuation Comeuppance

Is the seed and venture capital world about to go topsy turvy?  The roiling of the stock market has ripped the band aid off of the funding market.  Finally, we might be seeing Bill Gurley and Fred Wilson‘s cautionary words …






Startups And Corporates

Can startups and big mega corporations co-exist?  I used to think it was possible. I thought that linking startups and corporations was a good idea.  It sounds good on paper.  The reality is they are like oil and water. Sometimes …