What’s The Right Tax Rate For Carried Interest?

There’s a debate going on over carried interest.  Both Trump and Clinton have said they are going after hedge funds. Clinton has even advocated for a transaction tax, which is one of the stupidest taxes of all time.  Taxing the rich has become fashionable in the Obama era.

Taxes are nothing more than economic incentives.  If you want less of something, tax it.  Taxes raise the marginal costs of producing.

Our tax code is built on the notion of “fairness”.  However, when politicos and bureaucrats decide what’s fair, it’s never fair.  Lobbyists and corporations get loopholes and the rest of the people are left holding the bag.

In hedge funds, venture funds(VC), private equity funds(PE), and real estate funds, the tax treatment on income is different than if you held a 9 to 5 job.  It was for commodity trading as well.  Here is how they are taxed.

  • Commodity traders pay a 60/40 tax.  It’s a blended rate of 60% capital gains and 40% of the highest tax bracket no matter what they are.  Commodity traders also get tagged with the alternative minimum tax.  This was negotiated back in 1986 by Republican Senator Bob Dole.  Many commodity traders were paying 0% tax by putting on a spread at the end of the year, artificially losing money and rolling it into the next year.
  • Stock traders pay a rate depending on their level of income.  It can be as high as 39.5%.  If they make a lot of money and it’s their primary business, a lot of time they have to pay the alternative minimum tax.
  • Fund managers pay ordinary income taxes on the management fees they get from their fund.  For example, if you have a $10M fund and draw a 2% management fee, your income is $200,000/yr and you pay tax on it.  Where fund managers tax treatment changes is in gains from investments they make.  They pay straight capital gains of 20%.  It used to be 15% until it was raised.  On the first $10M of gains for a lot of VC investments, investors pay 0% tax.
  • Angel investors often get tax credits from states that can be used to defer taxes

Is this fair? In my opinion, that is exactly the wrong question to ask. The right question to ask is, “What kind of economic activity do I want to incentivize, and reward?

If society values innovation and startups, they should tax investments in them less than other activities.  They should also open it up to every American so everyone can take advantage of it.  Currently, investing in alternative asset classes is only available to accredited investors.

I am strongly in favor of a flat tax of 15% on all income, with precious few write offs.  Charitable deductions and other taxes you pay being about the only ones.  The government will be able to sustain itself just fine.

Investing in early stage startups is incredibly risky.  It’s very difficult to find people that want to take that risk.  It’s pretty easy to find people that say, “Oh, I would have invested in Facebook when Peter Thiel did.  How could you pass on that?”  Except, people did pass on Facebook.  Usually at early stages the company looks so stupid and outlandish that most people cannot envision, or find the intestinal fortitude to write a check to assume the risk.  They would prefer to wait for the stock to go public and invest then.  Or, buy real estate.

Recently I read two opposing views on the carried interest question.  One is from Alan Patricof.  He is a seasoned venture capital investor.  He has had a highly successful and lucrative career investing in startups.  His point is that if the general partner isn’t putting money in the fund, they shouldn’t get the favorable tax treatment.  I disagree with him because paying taxes isn’t a sign or function of patriotism.

Personally, I would never ever put money into any fund where the person running the fund didn’t have a large stake of their own personal wealth in the fund.  I want them to have skin in the game.  But, that’s a different topic.

The other side of the argument was clearly articulated by another New York venture investor.  Steve Brotman wrote a blogpost back in December of 2007 and it’s ideas ring true today.  In it, he explains that if you change the tax treatment all funds will just reposition/restructure themselves to appear different and slip through.  They will still pay lower taxes, it’s just the legal structures they operate under and invest through that will change.

Do we want to incentivize economic activity?  Do we want to reward people that invent new stuff, and invest in new stuff?  Do we want inventions to raise our standards of living?  Do we want a better life for everyone?

Then tax things accordingly.

 

Limited Government: Necessary For Growth

There is a small debate going on today over the role of government.  If you are at all interested in it, I’d encourage you to read this piece written by Cliff Asness back in 2009.  At the time, he was …






Constraints: They Can Be Good For You

One of the things that humans inherently prize is optionality. Commitment is hard. But, the truth is if you have every option in the world it becomes difficult to make a decision. Inertness sets in. Procrastination happens. Jim Brandenberg is …






Free Speech

Free speech is guaranteed by our Bill of Rights.  It’s core to America. Free speech is under assault by progressives all across the US-especially in our nation’s universities and public school systems.  Hopefully, we started to turn a corner yesterday. …






Why Twitter Has Staying Power

Yesterday Fred Wilson put out a Tweetstorm about Twitter.  I thought a little bit about it.  I recall an article in Barron’s back in 2007 or so.  It was about Twitter and an executive said, “Twitter is like a river. …






But, What If We’re Wrong

There are so many absolutes these days. Global warming is a perfect example. Let’s assume that we proceed with getting rid of all fossil fuels and put fossil fuel out of business worldwide. Then, global warming doesn’t happen, and we …






Robots Won’t Kill Us

I saw this video and thought it was totally cool. I think the young track star had quite a revelation about Jesse Owens athletic ability too. I’d love to see more athletes try this. Imagine today’s golf stars playing with …






Virtual Learning

There has been a lot of promises made about virtual learning over the years.  It’s getting better as technology improves.  Yesterday, on my drive back from Minnesota I heard an ad on the radio for Minnesota Virtual Academy.   There …






Best Cell Service

Since I got a cell phone in the 1990s, I have always had ATT cell service.  I find that no one actually likes their cell provider.  I wonder what else everyone is using, and where they are using it. ATT …






Louisiana Flood

IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO DONATE TO HELP FLOOD VICTIMS, HERE IS THE LINK. I have been out of touch with most of the news the past week or so.  I got some internet and saw there were huge rains …






How Regulators Destroy Markets

Was reading a book by John Allison “The Financial Crisis and the Free Market Cure”.  In it, he talks about the state of US markets and capitalism.   People are confused these days because they think we have actual capitalism …






When A Market Becomes A Casino

Was reading a short article on the plight of the cattle futures market. This has been happening over the course of the last seven years.  Seven years ago, the meat markets at the CME started to flip from open outcry …






Really Poorly Designed UX

What’s really poorly designed UX?  There are plenty of examples.  UX stands for “user experience”.  Without good user experience, you can’t get customers.  Since we are up in the Northwoods and run into and out of Internet/cell having good quick …






Co-Working Hits Movement

We had to run into town.  Grand Marais  (pop 1341) according to CNN it’s the coolest small town in America.  They just changed the runway at the airport from dirt to paved-and lengthened it so a jet can land.  One …






The Forest and the Trees

I am up in Minnesota for a week.  When we are up here, we tend to wind up doing some chores that require manual labor.  Gardening, transplanting trees, digging rocks, painting, trimming and cutting trees and burning them. There is …






Serendipity Doesn’t Happen By Being Passive

People talk about serendipity happening to them.  When it happens, it’s not because people were simply in the right place at the right time.  They usually are out in the world trying to make things happen. People often guard their …






The Grifters

Do you remember the movie The Grifters?  It was a dark movie, but in real life there are people like this that exist.  I have seen them circulate through the entrepreneur community and try to rip off investors and entrepreneurs. …






Best Hot Dog

I was at the Cubs game last night.  My brain is a little foggy.  I almost “walked home” after the Cubs won it.  (See what I did there)  When I go to baseball games, I eat a hot dog.  Wrigley …