Two Kinds of Discrimination With a Solution

There have been a lot of discrimination stories in the news.  Of course, last summer began the stories of Ferguson, MO.  But recently, Elaine Pao filed a discrimination lawsuit against her former firm, Kleiner Perkins.  Indiana passed a law on religious freedom and the backlash was quick.

I don’t have a government mandated answer to discrimination.  Virtually all the ones we have tried haven’t worked very well over time.  Discrimination still exists everywhere.  As a white male, in certain situations even I have felt the sting of discrimination.  It’s not constant, but I got a flavor of it and it doesn’t taste good.

I agree with some government legislation that ensures equal treatment under the law.  But, it seems like to me that every time someone feels disenfranchised, they are running to court.  Or, they are trying to create issues where they aren’t.  If every issue boils down to discrimination, then it’s hard to root out real discrimination.

Sometimes, people go through life with a chip on their shoulder looking and sniffing around for discrimination.  If you go through life with that attitude, you will find it everywhere.  At the same time, we can’t be naive and say it doesn’t exist.  There is a balance, and I would prefer the balance to tip slightly in favor of the assumption that the American society doesn’t discriminate.  If you think about life that way it’s easier to see when it does.

I don’t deny that networks matter. Sometimes it is hard to break into a network.  Sometimes it is not race/gender based but belief based.  Try being an out of the closet Republican in Chicago!  It’s up to the leaders of those networks to create the opportunities for people to break in.  At least if the way in is transparent, people can decide whether it’s worth it to try and break in.

If we agree that discrimination can’t be cured by government edict, then how does the problem get solved?

Markets.  Markets are the greatest merit based allocators of all resources known to mankind.  Economist Gary Becker published a thesis on discrimination back in 1957.  It was ground breaking.  After he passed away, Professor Kevin Murphy published a nice read on the thesis.  Becker was no stranger to discrimination himself.  He was denied acceptance at Ivy League schools because he was Jewish.  It’s one of the reasons he wound up at the University of Chicago.

The entire book, and Professor Murphy’s succinct analysis of it are worth reading.  Here is an excerpt of it and will give you a clue as to how Becker thought about the problem,

Employing this approach, Becker made a central observation: discrimination has consequences for people being discriminated against, as well as for the people engaged in it. If discrimination depresses the wages of black workers relative to those of similarly qualified whites, a discriminator who, say, does not want to hire black staff will have to pay more to hire white employees. This creates two costs: the black worker is paid less, and the discriminating employer incurs greater expense to obtain the same productivity.

Becker predicted that over time black workers would be pushed out of places where discrimination was prevalent and disproportionately work where discrimination was least evident. This, in turn, would reduce the impact on black workers relative to a world where they were allocated randomly across employers. Becker’s economic model reduced a charged social issue to an economic fundamental, supply and demand.

In the mad rush for talent at tech companies, and in any other highly skilled job, it’s advantageous NOT to discriminate.  My assumption is that in Silicon Valley and other tech centers, every company can use more engineering talent.  Color, gender, sexual orientation are the least of their worries.  All they want is people that can execute and get along with the rest of the team.  Companies that don’t discriminate should do better in the long run that companies who do.  The same applies for venture capitalists, law firms, and any other company we are thinking about.

I don’t look at anything other than merit when I write a check to a company.  If I were to discriminate on the basis of some artificial standard, it would cost me money.  It’s stupid.  In Chicago, I am seeing more women and non-white entrepreneurs.  Hopefully they feel accepted by the community.  At least the people I know in the community aren’t giving them the cold shoulder because of things that don’t matter.  The people I know in Chicago worry about a couple of things; can you execute and is your business worth getting involved in? Also, does your business fit my personal investment profile?



The Latest

  • The Great Unbundling
    Posted by on March 30th, 2015 at 8:21 am

    Have you seen this photo? Or this one from a while ago? A lot of great businesses have been built in the last ten years […]

  • Individual Choice is Better Than Bureaucratic Choice
    Posted by on March 29th, 2015 at 8:47 am

    Thought these two articles were interesting. The SEC ruled that companies can start selling up to $50M in securities within a 12 month period, subject […]

  • Pattern Recognition: Works in Trading and in VC
    Posted by on March 28th, 2015 at 8:24 am

    This is an interesting clip by Professor Steve Blank from Stanford.  He is talking about entrepreneurs and venture capitalists, but he easily could be talking […]

  • The Smallest Possible Leads to Biggest Possible
    Posted by on March 27th, 2015 at 7:16 am

    Hypergrowth.  Every startup wants it.  Every investor in a startup wants it too.  It means success.  It means money.  Hypergrowth also signifies that the startup […]

  • Throwback Thursday Photo
    Posted by on March 26th, 2015 at 12:07 pm

    This is a photo in a book targeted to kids about commodities.  Had to be taken in the late 1980’s.  That’s what the trading pits […]

  • What Should Your Business Model Look Like
    Posted by on March 26th, 2015 at 7:00 am

    Business model is one thing that someone considers before investing in a business.  At a certain point, the investor needs to decide is this business […]

  • Sometimes You Lead, Sometimes You Follow
    Posted by on March 25th, 2015 at 7:45 am

    In venture capital, most of the time it is best to be in front.  Be ahead of the curve and the herd.  That’s where the […]

  • Chicago Is Only As Good As It’s Hot Dog Stands
    Posted by on March 24th, 2015 at 9:03 am

    When I got my first job out of college, my sales territory was bordered by 95th street on the south side, Dixon, IL on the […]

  • Valuation Discussion From Two Pros: Are High Seed Valuations Here to Stay?
    Posted by on March 22nd, 2015 at 5:20 pm

    This is one of the reasons I like Twitter.  Sam Altman is one of the most respected people in seed/early stage investing.  He runs YCombinator, […]

  • Are You A Puppet?
    Posted by on March 22nd, 2015 at 10:02 am

    If you read ZeroHedge enough, you will eventually think dark thoughts all the time.  His blog is predicated on fear.  Sometimes there are some posts […]

  • Trade Following Apps
    Posted by on March 21st, 2015 at 9:36 am

    Over the course of the decade, I have seen a lot of companies doing “trade following”.  Essentially, it’s one trader that others sign up to […]

  • How To Win The Lotto Every Day
    Posted by on March 20th, 2015 at 8:06 am

    Twitter CEO Dick Costello said,  “You start one monster company, maybe you were lucky, maybe you were in the right place at the right time. You found […]

  • Too Good To Be True
    Posted by on March 19th, 2015 at 7:10 am

    Another financial whiz was locked up.  Remember Bernie Maddof?  He sits in a jail cell.  Remember the high school kid that supposedly made $72M trading? […]

  • Republican Congressman Aaron Schock Resigns
    Posted by on March 18th, 2015 at 8:04 am

    Republican Congressman Aaron Schock resigned.  Too bad.  He is young, 33.  He had a bright future in politics.  That being said, I think his resignation […]

  • 21 Million Bitcoins
    Posted by on March 17th, 2015 at 8:01 am

    Bitcoin startup 21 Inc raised $116M in venture capital money from several investors last week.  If you follow VC, the list of investors is a […]

  • Messing With Meerkat
    Posted by on March 16th, 2015 at 7:32 am

    Meerkat is a startup that is taking the social web by storm. It’s filled up my Twitter stream.  Twitter stopped Meerkat’s autotweet feature because it […]

  • Who Will Buy The Apple Watch?
    Posted by on March 15th, 2015 at 9:59 am

    The iWatch debuted to a yawn.  ($AAPL) The Apple cult used to wait breathlessly for new product announcements.  Steve Jobs would build them up, and […]